Jim Nemerovski – 11/7/07
State of Girls in Baseball in San Francisco – SFYBL All-Girls Baseball Division going into its third year: a proposal
by Jim Nemerovski, girlsbaseballleague.com and girlsbaseballleague.org
The issue:
Girls, their families and support system providers don’t know they already have a Baseball league of their own in San Francisco – or that they are welcome to play Baseball in the SFYBL Coed division if they are comfortable with that.
The obstacle:
Limited resources for a girls-only Baseball league compete with other well-established sports and leagues within SFYBL as well as offerings from other organizations.
The goal:
Provide Girls, their families and support system providers with logistics on ongoing clinics – teams in formation – around the city.
A transitional approach:
Provide access to entry-level development in SFYBL all-girls Baseball while also continuing to support girls playing at a high level in SFYBL Coed Baseball.
***Great benefit would come from working with other youth activity and sports
organizations to recognize girls who are only interested in Baseball to bring them together in one city-wide program despite divisions between these different organizations.***
Getting the word out now:
At 4 months out, we are in a good position to let all youth sports programmers know that the opportunity is here for girls to play Baseball: Inform public after school programs that girls Baseball is offered at after school program; work with independent youth activity organizations to get their staff and community involved; reach out to independent private and all-girls schools.
Promote and build the all-girls Baseball program beginning in the Winter:
Teams in SFYBL are based on existing and evolving rosters but only a very limited base exists from which to build similarly an all-girls league. Start building now: have Rec Centers include Baseball clinics and practices during Winter, inside as well as out considering weather. Promote a similar program among private organizations. The sessions would meet at least twice a month, each session focused on a specific skill development. These sessions would not need to be exclusive to girls but highlighting that they are for girls, too – maybe even discretely targeted marketing but allows for the two groups to show up at the same time, coached at a skill level rather than also strictly along gender lines.
These could also be an ad hock activity among those provided by after school and
latchkey programs. SFYBL would provide a manual and training clinics to staff.
Even if fewer girls arrive to these sessions, the regularity of them will build awareness for the Spring.
Coaching:
At the Rec site level start with whatever the skill set of the Director and staff will allow for. Many Rec directors and staff prefer T-Ball: a perfect level to start building all-girls Baseball. Again, at this level simply promoting that Baseball is for girls, too, will lead to bringing more kids to the field.
Bring skilled coaches to the program, earlier, from other sources. Among the private
contracted coach at the time the league was formed in 2005 one very successful all-sport coach was more interested in supporting a program that would have allowed him to develop players from a younger age: it would be much easier to offer to families, with long-term goals in site (including Softball opportunities and regional, national and international girls’ and women’s Baseball tournaments.)
School athletic directors will recommend their own sport-specific contracted coaches and older students. Community Outreach is an essential part of any Middle or High School curriculum. This could be managed as a program within existing after school programs, (the YMCA offers at Claire Lilienthal and Marina Middle School, for example.) Tap into a program in San Francisco that is now providing essential training to young people as coaches for inner city youth sports programs – more information including contacts on this existing local organization to follow.
Gathering and managing teams at the Rec Center Site level:
Each Rec center continues to offer all-girls Baseball with no preconception of how many may be interested or are needed to start practices. If 1 or 2 girls show up to a previously scheduled activity the Rec center builds from there.
As the number of girls interested grows, Rec centers work with one another to bring the girls together for skills clinics and Sandlot games distributing skill levels between two teams.
Full teams will eventually form and be able to play actual games within their own league. As skill level increases to parity with Coed league, if there are not enough teams formed, an all-girls team would consider playing in the SFYBL Coed division.
Number of teams:
Accept a minimum of two teams and grow from there; schedule of games TBD.
Size of teams:
Team size can vary at each regularly scheduled gathering of players without being fixed: if too small for actual game work on skill development, as occurs in SFYBL Coed today.
Providing for high skill levels:
Girls who already have skill from playing in other leagues are to be encouraged to
become leaders within the all-girl league. During practices as captains and managers they will conduct skill sessions under the guidance of the coach or athletic director. Playing side by side with these higher-skilled players the esteem and progress among the developing players will grow rapidly.
This can be the student’s Community Outreach program fulfillment as well.
Building through peers will empower the girls to take ownership of this program.
For now, highly developed players will prefer playing in the Coed division of SFYBL
sacrificing the opportunity to play with girls. That option will always be there for them: to play on a Coed team from a public facility or other private organization that includes girls.
If enough girls of a high skill level in the upper grade or age ranges emerge the option should exist for them to field an entire team of girls within the SFYBL Coed division. When enough teams have formed then we can build a all-girls competitive division into the league.
Age groups:
Initially offer Baseball as All-girls to each of two grade ranges: K-2; 3-5. Focusing on these at a Rec site level – and among established professional coaches and independent organizations – can develop into enough girls to play in either All-girl or Coed Middle School levels.
Baseball rules:
Modify the rules to accommodate the number and skill level of players who are interested.
Funding needs:
At this time, funding for getting the word out and scheduling field time is essential; funding for uniforms necessary, complete Baseball gear is required as it validates the choice to play Baseball made by the participants; equipment needs will include field and player’s gear but could be from shared equipment managed by a given Rec site for all SFYBL programs.
Conclusion:
It would be ideal to build on the ongoing efforts of SFYBL with the Women and Girls in Sports division of the San Francisco Recreation and Parks Department, the impetus
and vision of Excelsior Sports Club, and leadership training support from Team Up For
Youth. Many other GO and NGO programs were excited about this program two years
ago and did what they could to spread the word.
If we could continue with that approach, with more advance notice, strategy and planning our success rate may be well beyond any expectations.
===
(I was asked to provide recommendations to our local, San Francisco Police Athletic League (not affiliated with the California or National PAL organizations) by Executive Director, Maureen Carew, as San Francisco ramps up for Spring sports league registration. As the administrative branch within the San Francisco Youth Baseball League, Maureen’s concerns not stretching their organization too thin, defining their roles better going into the 2008 calendar, raised real concern about their ability to continue supporting the initiative.
As of 2006, San Francisco had only the second all-girls Baseball league in the United States of America; in 2007, the league received significantly less resource city-wide to sustain itself, despite millions of dollars targeted at inner-city youth programming, which would have significantly benefited from such a unique opportunity for girls. Recently, the third year came seriously into question considering major changes to city-wide league registration procedures and moving up the calendar by two months.
These recommendations include a synthesis of discussions with Deb Bettencourt from the Pawtucket, RI, Slaterettes, the only other nationally-recognized, all-girls Baseball league, now of 35 years; from conversations had with Mary Jo Stegeman, Founder, Chicago Pioneers, who is taking Girls Baseball to a new dimension, defining Tournament Baseball, tapping in to the Chicagoland area and others for players.
Considering the ideals and the realities in our community that provided the opening for our new league – particularly the sharp contrast in resource allocation in the past year and a half to build our own league, Softball has emerged as a higher priority to the Youth Sports leadership.)